Climate friendly propulsion technologies - Part 1 

A step towards a more sustainable future of aviation 

While public pressure forces the aviation industry to significantly reduce its carbon footprint, the industry itself also has set itself ambitious goals for decarbonization. Most major airports around the world committed themselves to NetZero. In addition, organizations such as ICAO and IATA pledged to drastically reduce the industry’s carbon footprint.

To meet these challenging targets, there is an increasing need to develop – and certify - new propulsion technologies. Kerosene, which is practically the only means of propulsion in aviation today, is almost entirely derived from fossil sources, and thus is a major carbon emitter. The industry needs alternative, carbon neutral propulsion technologies, such as

  • Hydrogen and 
  • Electric propulsion.

Yet, the development of such technologies takes a significant amount of time. Not only must these technologies be developed and certified, but also new aircraft need to be designed for such types of propulsion. Certification procedures for these new types of aircraft can take up to 10-15 years. Timelines for electric and hydrogen flying in notable scales reach to 2035 and beyond.

Thus, it is a challenging task for airlines as well as airports, to meet regulatory requirements and self-imposed targets. 

What is the current state of play and what is the implication for airports? This article is dedicated to the topic of Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF) and will be the first in a series of two articles that will deal with alternative, more environmentally friendly propulsion technologies currently under development or already deployed. 

It will help you navigate the complexities of a more sustainable aviation industry by exploring the different propulsion technologies and demonstrating their properties and benefits.  

Part 1: Sustainable Aviation Fuels

Even though Sustainable Aviation Fuels are not exactly a new propulsion technology, they will play a major role in the aviation industry’s pathway to NetZero. According to a study on innovative drives and fuels for more climate-friendly air traffic for the Office of Technology Assessment at the German Federal Parliament, SAFs and other biogenic fuels will account for roughly 70 % of the energy required to fuel flights [1]. The remaining 30 % will be powered by hydrogen with a share of 25 % and electric propulsion. Currently the two main drivers for the development and deployment of Sustainable Aviation Fuels are the ReFuelEU Regulation and the Carbon Taxation in 19 EU Countries.

[1] https://www.tab-beim-bundestag.de/projekte_innovative-antriebe-und-kraftstoffe-fur-einen-klimavertraeglicheren-luftverkehr.php

Refueling of an aircraft © Flughafen München GmbH

What are Sustainable Aviation Fuels?

Unlike conventional kerosene, Sustainable Aviation Fuels do not consist of fossil raw materials, such as crude oil. Thus, CO2 emissions of SAF are estimated to be 60-80 % lower than the emissions of kerosene, marking a real energy transition in aviation.

There are two types of SAF:

  • Biofuels: These sustainable aviation fuels are derived from a variety of feedstocks that are not in direct competition with food production, such as agricultural and forestry residues, solid household waste, used grease, but also algae. They are produced through complex processes which include thermochemical conversion and biochemical conversion.

  • eFuels / eKerosene: Currently, there are two main pathways to source eFuels, Methanol-to-Jet and Fischer-Tropsch Synthetic Paraffinic Kerosene (FT-SPK). These fuels are 100 % synthetic. While the Methanol-to-Jet pathway is still under evaluation and not approved for blending with fossil aviation fuels, it is already possible to use FT-SPK with a blend of up to 50 %. Unlike biofuels, eFuels have the potential of achieving zero carbon emissions, if the energy needed for the production process is sourced from 100 % renewable energies and the carbon dioxide comes from sustainable sources or direct air capture.

    Yet, as biofuels will not be sufficient to cover the demand for sustainable means of propulsion, the need for advancements in the production processes of eFuels is high. 

Drop-In

As SAF has a different chemical composition that conventional jet fuel, it must be blended with regular fuel, the so-called drop-in. This ensures all critical specifications for safe operations in aircraft systems are met and the standards set by ASTM D1655 are fulfilled. The blend ratio can vary in this context, currently regulatory bodies such as EASA and FAA have approved blend ratios up to 50 %. A 100 % SAF use in commercial aviation is currently still being researched with first commercial flights already powered by 100 % SAF. The unknown in this matter is still the long-term impacts of Sustainable Aviation Fuels on jet engines and especially its gaskets.

Blended fuel also ensures compatibility with existing infrastructure, which does not have to be modified for SAF.

As production of SAF today is still relatively expensive and thus limited, blending SAF with conventional jet fuel helps gradually increasing the share of SAF under economic considerations. Eventually, production figures will have to be ramped up. 


Implications for airports

Once a Sustainable Aviation Fuel is certified as aviation turbine fuel according to ASTM D1655, it is allowed to be dropped-in conventional jet kerosene. Thus, it can be handled in the same way conventional fuel is handled, no alternations need to be made to the existing fueling infrastructure. Airports need to monitor the fuel farms, though, and ensure that certified drop-in rates are not exceeded. 

Fuel farm at Munich Airport © Flughafen München GmbH

ReFuelEU Aviation Regulation

The ReFuelEU Aviation Regulation, set to become effective in 2025, aims to promote the use of SAF in the aviation sector, and thus significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It requires all aviation fuel providers in the EU to provide a minimum share of 2 % SAF as of 2025, increasing over time to reach at least 63 % by 2050.

The European Regulation is supposed to stimulate technological advancements in the sector of green aviation fuels in the EU, making Europe a leader in sustainable aviation.

Yet, In case of long-haul flights, SAFs will most likely remain the only solution beyond 2050, as neither electric nor hydrogen propulsion technologies will be able to provide the necessary power for these flights in the foreseeable future.

Balance Sheet Consumption

Despite the new European Regulation, which requires Airlines starting in 2025 to take up at least 2 % of their kerosene consumption as SAF, the actual consumption of sustainable aviation fuels by an airline will only be statistical. Airlines are obliged to order a minimum share of SAF, which will then be introduced into the fueling system of an airport. It is not relevant in this context if this amount of SAF is actually delivered to the respective airline or uplifted to other airlines.

To keep supply chains sustainable, it makes even more sense to introduce SAF in the proximity of the refinery producing the fuel. There is no difference for the environment and the aviation sector’s global carbon footprint where the Sustainable Aviation Fuel is used and who is consuming it.

Sustainable aviation: a major task for airlines as well as airports © Flughafen München GmbH

Conclusion

Sustainable Aviation Fuels have the potential to significantly reduce carbon emissions in aviation, helping airports and airlines alike to meet regulatory obligations and fulfill their self-imposed sustainability commitments. Ongoing research and technological advances will further improve efficiency, scalability, and cost-effectiveness of such fuels. The largest impact on the industry’s carbon footprint will only be made through completely emission-free propulsion technologies, such as electric or hydrogen flying, but the development of these technologies still will take a significant amount of time and require investments in R&D, acquisition and infrastructure.

Until these technologies are available for wide-scale application, Sustainable Aviation Fuels represent an alternative propulsion technology that will make a significant contribution to reducing emissions and pave the way to carbon neutral flying. In addition, SAFs offer the advantage of being easy to use with existing fueling infrastructure and aircraft. Hydrogen or electric flying alternatives, on the other hand, require new types of aircraft, and a comprehensive charging respectively fueling infrastructure, which first has to be developed and certified. 


Author

Michael Obermaier

Michael Obermaier

Consultant

Contact us!

Munich Airport International supports airports worldwide in tackling their sustainability challenges. Contact our sustainabiltiy expert Michael Obermaier for further information!